What is a Clawback Claim in NJ Bankruptcy?

When you hear the term “clawback” in reference to bankruptcy, your mind may go to high-profile cases like the Bernie Madoff Ponzi scheme bankruptcy or similar cases with Lehman Brothers, Bayou Hedge Fund, Nine West, and more. But clawback provisions in the U.S. Bankruptcy Code are tools that can be used in any bankruptcy.
A bankruptcy clawback can potentially allow for the recovery of assets transferred out of your ownership in the 90 days before bankruptcy. The purpose of a clawback is to ensure equal and fair treatment of all creditors and to deter bankruptcy filers from engaging in fraudulent activities. If you are being asked to return funds in a clawback situation, it is important that you understand your rights and what kind of legal defenses are available to you. Veitengruber Law can help you assess the claim and determine the best way to protect your assets.
What does a clawback action do?
In the Bankruptcy Code, the clawback action, also known as an avoidance action, is a policy intended to ensure that all creditors are paid back equally. In all types of bankruptcy proceedings, the legal processes are not adversarial or litigation-based. Bankruptcy is intended to give folks a path towards better financial health—not punish them for financial mistakes. But clawback actions are separate legal proceedings that are referred to as bankruptcy litigation.
Sections 547 and 548 of the Bankruptcy Code authorize the trustee or debtor in possession to “claw back” asset transfers made by the debtor prior to bankruptcy.
- Fraud deterrent: Giving bankruptcy trustees the authority to clawback assets transferred in the 90-days prior to a bankruptcy filing is intended to help deter debtors from fraudulent activity. Some debtors may seek to hide or get rid of assets before filing for bankruptcy to make their case more personally favorable. But this is illegal, and the clawback option allows trustees the ability to recoup these funds.
- Equity: All creditors are supposed to be treated fairly under the bankruptcy code. The clawback action gives every creditor the opportunity to share in the debtor's assets, rather than favoring one creditor over another.
- Estate preservation: Clawback provisions allow recovery of assets belonging to the bankruptcy estate, thereby increasing the resources available to satisfy creditor claims.
What is the timeframe?
The timeframe to reclaim transferred assets depends on the circumstances surrounding the transfers.
One kind of transfer is called a preferential transfer. Under section 547 of the Bankruptcy Code, if the debtor is insolvent, any preferential payments made in the 90 days prior to filing for bankruptcy can be clawed back. This 90-day period can be extended to one year if the recipient of the payment or asset transfer is considered an “insider.” An insider would be a relative, close friend, or business partner. This often happens when insolvent individuals choose to repay debt owed to someone they know personally rather than the debt they owe other creditors.
Another kind of transfer is fraudulent transfers, covered under section 548 of the Bankruptcy Code. This is any movement of funds or assets out of the debtors possession for “less than reasonable value: while the debtor was insolvent. The lookback period for this is two years under federal law and up to four years under NJ law. So, for example, if you “sell” a vehicle worth $10,000 to a relative for $500 to avoid losing the vehicle through bankruptcy, that is considered fraud. Gifting large sums of money to friends, relatives, and other close associates is also fraud.
What is the clawback process like?
The bankruptcy trustee can initiate a clawback action by filing a complaint with the bankruptcy court. The complaint seeks court approval to use the clawback provision to retrieve assets transferred in the above-mentioned time frames. The complaint will legally involve the entity or individual who received the assets in the bankruptcy proceedings.
From there, the funds will be reabsorbed into the bankruptcy estate, and the court will include these new assets in its equitable distribution to all creditors.
What cannot be included in a clawback action?
Generally, clawback actions cannot be brought forth to recover regular, timely payments to secured lenders. These payments are considered payments for value received. This would be like your mortgage, car loan, or other secured debt payments. You do not have to stop making regular payments on your debt out of fear that the payments will lead to clawback claims in bankruptcy.
However, if the payments were abnormally large, above your normal monthly payment amounts, or non-routine, there could be a case for your trustee to attempt to claw back those funds.
Can I legally defend myself from clawback claims?
If you are facing a clawback claim, it is critical to understand your rights and any potential defenses you can use in court. Common clawback legal defences include:
1. Ordinary Course of Business
The debtor must prove that the payment was made for a debt incurred in the ordinary course of business. This is typically proved by showing historical patterns. This defense is typically used in Chapter 11 bankruptcy to show that debt incurred by a business or entity was legitimate for the business's operations.
2. Good Faith
Good-faith arguments are made to show that a debtor acted honestly and transparently, and made a sincere attempt to reorganize or repay debts. Many folks who find themselves dealing with clawback claims did not intentionally set out to commit fraud. When reviewing a good-faith argument, the court will look at the “totality of the circumstances” to make a decision about the intention behind large sum payments in the time before a bankruptcy filing.
3. Statute of Limitations
If your assets were transferred outside of the federal or state statute of limitations, they are not eligible for a clawback claim. So, if you sold a property below value to your child ten years ago, this transfer cannot be considered for a clawback claim. Attempts to include these assets through clawback actions can be dismissed in court.
How can I prevent bankruptcy clawback actions?
Transfers of assets in the months and years before a bankruptcy filing are often made in complete innocence. Not every debtor who finds themselves dealing with a clawback action did anything attempting to defraud the court or their creditors. But unintentional violations of the Bankruptcy Code can still result in clawback actions.
The best way to prevent clawback actions is to work with an experienced bankruptcy attorney. You need to be fully transparent with your lawyer and disclose all recent transfers of money or assets. They can help you determine if any actions could be considered fraudulent and how to deal with those issues before you open a bankruptcy case.
Veitengruber Law is well-versed in New Jersey bankruptcy law. We understand the intricate complexities of bankruptcy proceedings. In adversary proceedings, clawback actions require different legal skills than in a typical bankruptcy case. Veitengruber Law has experience with bankruptcy litigation. Let us help you protect your assets.








