What is Partition Action in New Jersey?

It is common for parents to leave their home to their children in their estate plan. A home is likely to be the largest asset a person has at the end of their life, and it makes sense that parents want to share this asset with their children. Where things get complicated, however, is when a parent leaves property in equal parts to multiple siblings without specifying how it should be divided. This can frequently lead to disagreements.
Some siblings may view the property more sentimentally, wishing to live in the home themselves or keep it in the family. Other siblings may view the property as a means of generating income, either by selling the home or setting it up as a rental. Disagreements can arise among siblings dealing with different life circumstances, financial needs, and aspirations.
When these disagreements cannot be resolved with compromise, a legal solution may be required to allow all parties to move forward. This is called a partition action.
What is a partition action?
A partition action is a legal process through which co-owners of a property can divide and distribute the property. This legal recourse is normally taken when co-owners cannot agree on how to manage or utilize the property. A third party, such as a judge, will review the case details and determine how the property should be divided in accordance with legal precedent. The goal is to find a solution that is fair, equitable, and in the best interest of all parties involved.
Types of Partition Actions
1. Partition By Sale
In this partition, the co-owned property is sold, and the profits are divided among the co-owners. Everyone will receive an equitable share of the proceeds and can use their portion as they wish. There will be no more co-owned property, so the disagreement is resolved as well. The partition by sale can be an issue for siblings who have an emotional attachment to the property, intend to live in it, or are financially dependent on it as a source of income.
2. Partition In Kind
This kind of partition physically divides the property among the co-owners. This is more likely to be an option for larger plots of land. Each co-owner receives an equitable share of the property and can use their portion however they want. However, physically dividing the property can decrease its value. It can also make it harder to find buyers if one owner is looking to sell the property.
3. Partition By Appraisal
Partition by appraisal involves an appraiser determining the property's value so that one party can pay the other the amount they would receive if the property were sold. This way, one sibling can keep the property and own it outright, while the other sibling (or siblings) receive their fair share now. This can be a great option if the person who wants to keep the property has the means to buy out the other co-owners. Also, depending on the market and how the property is appraised, the sibling keeping the property may have to pay out far more than they want or can afford. On the flip side, if the property is appraised for less, the siblings getting bought out may feel they are getting the short end of the stick.
Final Thoughts
Taking a family member to court can be a life-altering event. Your relationship may never be the same again. Before you initiate a partition action, consider whether there are any other options to resolve your conflict without taking legal action. Consider if the outcome—even if it is the outcome you desire—is really worth it. Negotiation, mediation, and compromise are typically the best path forward for all.
For parents planning to leave property to multiple children, having conversations with your children about your expectations for dividing property can help alleviate any conflicts when you are gone. Veitengruber Law is an experienced estate planning attorney. We work with folks in NJ to ensure their assets are protected during their lifetime and after. We can help you establish an estate plan that minimizes the risk of conflict among your heirs.






